They're Real Push-Up Eyeliner

benefit Cosmetics

Created with Sketch.

2.2

446 reviews
23%
would repurchase
2.7/5
package quality
price range
Write Review

    Reviews

    Reviews

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    butterfly1968

    10 years ago

    Ugh. I suckered in to buying this based on a rave write up on Into the Gloss. If ever there was confirmation that they are being paid for their articles just like every fashion/beauty magazine...

    About reviewer (45 reviews)

    Age44-55

    SkinNormal

    HairBlond

    EyesBlue

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    Pyxiwulf

    10 years ago

    Gums up on the pen terribly and clumps off the eye despite pulling out all the tricks. Also transfers from upper eye to under eye and leaves awful raccoon eyes despite powder setting. The gel is...

    About reviewer (2 reviews)

    Age36-43

    SkinOily, Fair-Medium

    HairRed

    EyesBlue

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    nataliebrown17

    10 years ago

    Had my eye on this product since it came out, at £18 plus I assumed it would be amazing and also because they're real mascara is good. However I couldn't have been more wrong. This liner is a...

    About reviewer (1 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinCombination, Fair

    HairBrunette

    EyesBlue

    3.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    alicedvv

    10 years ago

    I have mixed feelings about this product. Frankly, variations of cateye makeup have been my routine for around five years now, so granted I tried quite a few eyeliner formulas. While it is true...

    About reviewer (2 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinNormal, Fair-Medium

    HairBrown

    EyesHazel

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    darkskyequeen

    10 years ago

    So sad that this didn't work for me :( It applied soo beautifully when I tried it for the first time. I thought wow this is HG but then as the days wore on it was another story. The formula seemed...

    About reviewer (63 reviews)

    Age36-43

    SkinOily, Medium Brown, Warm

    HairBlack, Wavy, Medium

    EyesBrown

    3.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    Jdeliz

    10 years ago

    Had the victims of the eruption of Mount Vesuvius (79 AD) been wearing this eyeliner that tragic day, at least their eyelash lines would have been recovered intact. In an attempt to perfect an...

    About reviewer (42 reviews)

    Age30-35

    SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Neutral

    HairRed, Wavy, Fine

    EyesHazel

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    tanny1

    10 years ago

    This eyeliner is shockingly bad. This eyeliner is extremely hard to use its so dry and the matte finish is just disappointing. For how much they charge you for this product they should be arrested!

    About reviewer (25 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinCombination, Medium Brown

    HairBlack

    EyesBrown

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    jadesimps

    10 years ago

    I was really excited for this product to launch, bought it the day it came out. I wanted to love it, I really did. The packaging is easy enough to use, twist 2 clicks, and apply. It's too hard to...

    About reviewer (1 reviews)

    Age25-29

    SkinSensitive, Fair

    HairRed

    EyesGreen

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    Puggurl

    10 years ago

    Awful!!!! The product globs out, you have no time to spread it before it sets, it's just awful. I was so excited about this product, but Benefit didn't pull it off.

    About reviewer (7 reviews)

    Age36-43

    SkinDry, Fair

    HairBlond

    EyesHazel

    2.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    Cfinch1

    10 years ago

    Although the idea is fabulous, Benefit did not carry it out well. I was very dissapointed with the product. Flaky, streaky, hard to control how much comes out. I do winged eyeliner everyday and I...

    About reviewer (1 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinDry, Olive

    HairRed

    EyesBrown

    5.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    urbanangel007

    10 years ago

    I honestly don't know why this product is getting sooo many bad reviews..I LOVE it..it's a bit pricey but it's excellent! A major complaint seems to be waste but just give it one turn and just...

    About reviewer (8 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinSensitive, Fair-Medium

    HairBlack

    EyesBrown

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    csquared14

    10 years ago

    Oh, Benefit. I put actual effort into trying to like you. If makeup quality came down to pretty packaging, you would so win. This is a terrible, overpriced product. ELF's $1 liner works better....

    About reviewer (111 reviews)

    Age25-29

    SkinAcne-prone, Medium, Warm

    HairBlack, Wavy, Medium

    EyesBrown

    2.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    Mpersh

    10 years ago

    Once you finally get this liner on it looks pretty good, and I find it stays put very well. I don't like the twist up pen. The applicator wastes too much product and for the price, the last thing...

    About reviewer (11 reviews)

    Age44-55

    SkinCombination, Medium, Not Sure

    HairBrunette, Curly, Medium

    EyesGreen

    2.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    marthamihm

    10 years ago

    I had to return this. The applicator was actually much harder than other liquid eyeliners to use for me. It was hard not to get too much product. I found the formulation flaky as well.

    About reviewer (17 reviews)

    Age36-43

    SkinCombination, Fair-Medium

    HairBlond

    EyesBlue

    4.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    LittleMissBree

    10 years ago

    Overall 4/5. Not quiet my holy grail eyeliner. But still very good.

    About reviewer (2 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinSensitive, Fair

    HairBlond

    EyesGreen

    2.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    HotPinkLips101

    10 years ago

    Very black, very matte, good pigmentation, but the applicator sucks, it does not make it easier to apply,.u waste a ridiculous amount of product. I do not recommend this.. I'll be returning it today

    About reviewer (24 reviews)

    Age30-35

    SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Neutral

    HairBlack, Wavy, Fine

    EyesBrown

    3.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    teenybutton

    10 years ago

    I have mixed feelings about this eyeliner. I love the ease of application and the fact that I have no brushes to clean, but I think it's overpriced for the amount of product you receive, and the...

    About reviewer (5 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Warm

    HairBrown, Wavy, Coarse

    EyesBrown

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    lvrgurl77

    10 years ago

    Yuck super messy . Very difficult to use. Very disappointed seem like so easy to make the perfect cat eye loom and no horrible product! Don't waste your $$$

    About reviewer (18 reviews)

    Age30-35

    SkinNormal, Medium

    HairBrown

    EyesBrown

    2.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    Ridaaxo

    10 years ago

    So disappointed in this! Had such high hopes, especially since I love the They're real mascara. Application is unnecessarily complicated, the base has to be twisted to get the product out, which...

    About reviewer (3 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinCombination, Olive

    HairBrunette

    EyesBrown

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    principessa24

    10 years ago

    THE. WORST. LINER. EVER. I've tried a lot of different liners -- liquid, gel, pencil and kajal. This is far and away the worst one I have ever tried. The click-up pen format is bad, I either...

    About reviewer (17 reviews)

    Age25-29

    SkinCombination, Tan, Warm

    HairBlack, Other, Other

    EyesBrown

    Related Searches
    benefit Cosmetics / Eyeliner