They're Real Push-Up Eyeliner

benefit Cosmetics

Created with Sketch.

2.2

446 reviews
23%
would repurchase
2.7/5
package quality
price range
Write Review

    Reviews

    Reviews

    2.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    UbiquityEssence

    10 years ago

    I received this as a sample. I have super oily skin and after a few hours this liner smudged everywhere. Application was difficult to apply and I am pretty pro at doing at a cat eye. I will...

    About reviewer (89 reviews)

    Age25-29

    SkinAcne-prone, Fair-Medium, Cool

    HairBlack, Straight, Fine

    EyesBrown

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    brighteyes22

    10 years ago

    Not a fan. It does not make a smooth, straight line, no matter how hard you try. It's not pigmented. Returned it. Cannot recommend

    About reviewer (37 reviews)

    Age30-35

    SkinAcne-prone, Olive, Not Sure

    HairBrown, Other, Other

    EyesBrown

    4.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    AQuestionofLust

    10 years ago

    This product takes some getting used to, but give it a chance! The following experience is based on my experience using a brand new pen on already oily lids without a primer on a humid NYC...

    About reviewer (37 reviews)

    Age30-35

    SkinSensitive, Fair-Medium, Warm

    HairBrunette, Wavy, Fine

    EyesBrown

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    SMaj

    10 years ago

    This is the worst eyeliner I have ever used. Ever! I thought I would give this a go and see if I liked it, the idea itself sounds brilliant. Gel formula in a pen applicator with precision tapering...

    About reviewer (66 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinAcne-prone, Fair-Medium

    HairBlack

    EyesBrown

    2.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    Scalata

    10 years ago

    I noticed my eyes became red & irritated after using this. I wore it to go out with a gf for a movie & when I looked at the mirror my eyelids had black lines from it smearing. Loved the pigment...

    About reviewer (6 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinCombination, Tan

    HairBrunette

    EyesBrown

    2.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    alyssamspencer

    10 years ago

    I was very disappointed with this eyeliner. After reading about it, I bought it as soon as it came out. It is very difficult to apply - the packaging is just awful. It leaks out, and barely and...

    About reviewer (20 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinNormal, Fair-Medium

    HairBrunette

    EyesHazel

    4.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    plasticinequeen

    10 years ago

    I usually struggle with eyeliner and always worry I'm doing it wrong but this makes it so easy. It lasts all day on my eyelids and comes off pretty easily too (as long as you use a suitable...

    About reviewer (1 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinSensitive, Fair

    HairBrunette

    EyesBrown

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    miller13

    10 years ago

    Unfortunately, this didn't work out for me. I have oily eyelids so it smudged quite a bit. I was embarrassed to learn this after I came out of a meeting at work - my eyeliner was quite smudged...

    About reviewer (8 reviews)

    Age44-55

    SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Warm

    HairBlond, Wavy, Medium

    EyesGreen

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    trixie1803

    10 years ago

    What an overhyped piece of crud. I don't even care enough to trash it, just no. Save 'yo money.

    About reviewer (80 reviews)

    Age56 & Over

    SkinOily

    HairBrown

    EyesBrown

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    snagel

    10 years ago

    This stuff is awful. It never comes out in a consistent flow. It skips and if you try to build it, and go over the line, it pulls it right off and leaves patchy spots. When I moved the liner...

    About reviewer (2 reviews)

    Age44-55

    SkinOther, Fair

    HairBrown

    EyesBrown

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    SusanMary

    10 years ago

    I threw it away. Just plopped it in my trash can. It was that bad. I had high hopes for this because I think I am the population for which it was intended. I have hooded eyes and nearly always...

    About reviewer (45 reviews)

    Age56 & Over

    SkinAcne-prone, Fair, Neutral

    HairBlond, Wavy, Coarse

    EyesBrown

    2.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    jkpetite

    10 years ago

    Ok. I have to update my review. This stuff has gone from great to mediocre after a few uses. It now runs and the formula has become thick & clumpy - which makes application challenging. I used to...

    About reviewer (327 reviews)

    Age36-43

    SkinDry, Medium, Warm

    HairBrunette, Wavy, Coarse

    EyesHazel

    3.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    pandabear99

    10 years ago

    It looks great but i’ll skip it anyway. The product is too difficult to work with for me and it was a bit hard to take off. Although I love the brand Benefit.

    About reviewer (4 reviews)

    Age25-29

    SkinOther, Medium

    HairOther

    EyesOther

    2.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    six30

    10 years ago

    This product was totally not for me. It may be the shape of my Asian eyelids, but I found the product smudged and flaked after a half hour. Plus, you need to click multiple times to get the...

    About reviewer (31 reviews)

    Age44-55

    SkinSensitive, Fair-Medium, Neutral

    HairBlack, Straight, Medium

    EyesBrown

    2.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    AnaPR

    10 years ago

    I've lurked to Olympian levels on this site. For years, I've read all of your reviews and hard work and never once contributed. This liner has inspired me to get off my lazy butt and shout it...

    About reviewer (6 reviews)

    Age30-35

    SkinCombination, Tan

    HairBlack

    EyesBrown

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    Hothead

    10 years ago

    I got this is as a sample. Thank the Lord I did not spend cold hard cash on this. It is a waste of money. Hard to use and hey I use all of the gel liners and liquid liners for the last 30...

    About reviewer (947 reviews)

    Age44-55

    SkinNormal, Fair, Warm

    HairBrown, Straight, Medium

    EyesHazel

    3.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    vagabondking

    10 years ago

    not worth the hype. i was so looking forward to this eyeliner, but became sorely disappointed even at the first use. it's not exactly a bad eyeliner, but for its price, there are definitely better...

    About reviewer (38 reviews)

    Age25-29

    SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Neutral

    HairBlack, Straight, Medium

    EyesBrown

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    patricew

    10 years ago

    Just bought this and can't even get the eyeliner out onto the brush. It's being returned.

    About reviewer (5 reviews)

    Age56 & Over

    SkinCombination, Fair-Medium

    HairBlond

    EyesBlue

    2.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    snugglebunnyjm

    10 years ago

    Meh. I like gel eyeliner on my top lids only, but I generally have a hard time getting the lines as thin and close to the lash line as I'd like. I picked this up in Ulta because I thought it would...

    About reviewer (103 reviews)

    Age30-35

    SkinSensitive, Fair

    HairBrunette

    EyesBlue

    5.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    ritables

    10 years ago

    LOVE Ive purchased this many times. Takes a learning curve but if/once mastered is the most indelible line ever. I teach hot yoga; my eyeliner needs are extreme. Warning: can be rage-inducing...

    About reviewer (81 reviews)

    Age44-55

    SkinNormal, Medium, Warm

    HairBlack, Straight, Fine

    EyesBrown

    Related Searches
    benefit Cosmetics / Eyeliner