Maple and Mums is my go-to for black eyeliner, wet or dry. It doesn't have as much sparkle as it looks like it does, though. I wasn't really getting it for the sparkle, so no disappointment there...
About reviewer (61 reviews)
AgeUnder 18
SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Not Sure
HairBrown, Straight, Medium
EyesHazel