I use Smashbox 15h, .3
I am having this exact same dilemma, my HG is ELDW but I have decided to go cruelty-free ++
Well, I just ordered. :-) I have a pro discount with Smashbox, so I got it for $16. ++
Smashbox O-Glow
Yes, I do; with some caveats ++
Smashbox Punked is amazing; you can layer to a smokey eye look or use little to look all natural
Here's some from my spreadsheet; of course, not every single color is cool, but these all ++
Just a contour shade from Smashbox Cali Contour Palette
Both liquid - KvD Everlasting and Smashbox Always On
Temptalia is a good idea. Here's a few from my spreadsheet, not all are singles ++