Catrice
Maybelline IAR has been a fav of mine for yrs. Recently disc. Joah - the one with the sponge tip. +
Joah Make Her Gel-ous is sold at some CVS locations. If you like felt tip, NYX has a nice grey.
It’s really hard to find a charcoal gray shade, believe me, I’ve been looking++
For dark grey liner, I'd recommend Inglot AMG Gel, Joah Make Her Gelous (pencil), NYX (felt tip)++
Joah (Korean brand at CVS) has a slanted tip pencil that’s awesome and there’s +
Nearly all pencil or automated pencil liners with exception of Ardency Inn, MUFE, Joah, MUA brands
HE: Inglot AMC Gel, Shiseido Inkstroke & Stila Stay All Day; DS: NYX Epic Ink & NYX Strictly Vinyl++
Old school Jordana actually. Also the CVS Kbeauty line Joah has great creamy and matte lipsticks
Inglot (Gel); liquids-Kiko Milano, Stila Stay All Day, NYX & (pencil) Ardency Inn, Joah, MUFE, MUA