Classic Eye Pencil in Black

I had a brown pencil from 3 years ago that i loved. It was ling lasting and creamy esp in the water line. That one was made in germany. I recently bought a black one and theis one does not stay on...

This is such a good eye pencil that I'm tossing several other pencils in my makeup drawer. This goes on very smooth, with no waxy residue and no dragging. It will smudge and possibly smear due to...