Moisturizing eye makeup remover liquid

I really did not like this product. The first thing to turn me off was the nail polish remover like smell. Secondly, my normal L'oreal eye makeup remover takes my eye makeup off with one cotton...

Yuck! This stuff left an awful, greasy film around my eyes that wouldn't even rinse off with water - I had to use a tissue to rub it off. Don't waste your money!