Aqua Eyes - Star Black 1L

MAKE UP FOR EVER

Created with Sketch.

3.9

39 reviews
69%
would repurchase
4.0/5
package quality
price range
Write Review

    Reviews

    Reviews

    3.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    faramaobscena

    9 years ago

    I wanted an eyeliner that is subtle enough to be used every day. This is the right color and texture, unfortunately it doesn't stay on :( which is a huge disappointment for me, because that was...

    About reviewer (13 reviews)

    Age30-35

    SkinAcne-prone, Other

    HairBlack

    EyesBlue

    5.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    elbits

    9 years ago

    This is my everyday eyeliner. I have very oily eyelids and nothing stays put except this!!! The price is a bit high, but I like the product and shade enough that it's worth it. I would definitely...

    About reviewer (7 reviews)

    Age36-43

    SkinOily, Fair-Medium

    HairBlond

    EyesOther

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    eyiann

    9 years ago

    Very unhappy with this one. After spending amounts of money to find a pencil that doesn't smudge, I thought buying a more expensive product would do the job, but it gave me the racoon eyes after 1...

    About reviewer (4 reviews)

    Age36-43

    SkinCombination, Medium, Not Sure

    HairBrunette, Wavy, Medium

    EyesBlack

    5.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    ChennyPenn

    13 years ago

    Total HG. As we all know, black-black can actually make the eyes appear smaller. Hence, this charcoal-black is the answer. It's my everyday liner that works for the office, happy hour, dinner,...

    About reviewer (20 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinCombination, Fair-Medium

    HairBlack

    EyesBrown

    4.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    ristastic

    13 years ago

    This is my HG everyday eyeliner. I have very oily eyelids and nothing stays put except this and 24/7. I alternate between the two depending on which color I want. The Make Up For Ever 1L I find to...

    About reviewer (8 reviews)

    Age36-43

    SkinOily, Medium

    HairBrunette

    EyesBrown

    4.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    LeslieMUA

    13 years ago

    This is my favorite black eyeliner, and I like it because it's a little softer and low-key than your typical black liner. If I'm doing a really intense, dark smokey eye, I'll reach for something a...

    About reviewer (32 reviews)

    Age30-35

    SkinDry, Fair-Medium, Cool

    HairBrunette, Wavy, Medium

    EyesHazel

    3.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    istuart

    14 years ago

    This liner is super soft and creamy and the color is rich, even intense. But the color smudges and runs right off your water line; it needs to be set with a powder shadow. So, overall not awful but...

    About reviewer (23 reviews)

    Age44-55

    SkinOily, Medium, Neutral

    HairBrunette, Straight, Fine

    EyesBrown

    2.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    mcalcia

    14 years ago

    This color is kind of a "soft black", it's almost charcoal. The color is not as rich as I expected and it doesn't show up on your waterline. Doesn't last at all (just about 2-3 hours) and smudges a...

    About reviewer (69 reviews)

    Age25-29

    SkinDry, Fair, Not Sure

    HairBrown, Straight, Fine

    EyesBrown

    5.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    kawiki

    14 years ago

    Blendable, rich color, and waterproof. What more could you ask for?

    About reviewer (87 reviews)

    AgeUnder 18

    SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Warm

    HairBlond, Straight, Fine

    EyesBlue

    5.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    briii

    15 years ago

    this is a great eyeliner. i have this in 2l as well. it is really hard for me to find a black eyeliner that is extremely dark and has good staying power,and this eyeliner has both of those...

    About reviewer (181 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinNormal, Fair-Medium, Not Sure

    HairBrunette, Other, Other

    EyesBlue

    4.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    PeachFuzzz

    15 years ago

    I continue to purchase this eyeliner. I like the smooth application. It does smudge but not as bad as some eyeliners. I hate buying pencil liners but this is worth it.

    About reviewer (118 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinAcne-prone, Fair-Medium, Warm

    HairBlack, Wavy, Coarse

    EyesHazel

    5.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    suzannaelektra

    15 years ago

    HG. HG. HG. Works well with my oily eye lids...doesn't smudge or crease and removes easily with water proof makeup remover. Would rebuy over and over again. Really intense black shade...I've tried...

    About reviewer (387 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinCombination, Medium, Warm

    HairBlack, Straight, Medium

    EyesHazel

    4.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    dumbdookie

    15 years ago

    I've purchased and tried using a few other eyeliner pencils, and this one by far is the best so far (of course, compared to my recent discovery of gel eyeliners, this is still far below in...

    About reviewer (20 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinCombination, Fair, Not Sure

    HairBlack, Straight, Other

    EyesBrown

    3.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    groovinchic

    15 years ago

    I really don't get the hype with this product. I love my Shi creme eyeliner because it doesn't budge, but was looking for a quickie pencil. After reading some good reviews on MUFE, and specifically...

    About reviewer (194 reviews)

    Age30-35

    SkinAcne-prone, Fair-Medium, Not Sure

    HairBrunette, Other, Other

    EyesBrown

    4.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    Sophia1105

    16 years ago

    More of a silver gray on me, a bit too flashy, just wanted a muted alternative to black. Didn't last long enough either. That said, very creamy and easy to apply, thus 4/5 as most tear up my eyes....

    About reviewer (295 reviews)

    Age25-29

    SkinSensitive, Medium, Warm

    HairBrunette, Straight, Fine

    EyesGreen

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    patcher

    16 years ago

    I don't get it. This product smudged and gave me raccoon eyes. I used it for a month and then returned it to Sephora.

    About reviewer (11 reviews)

    Age56 & Over

    SkinNormal

    HairBlond

    EyesBlue

    4.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    ekim413

    16 years ago

    After trying so many eyeliners only to have them smudge and give me panda eyes I just assumed that was the case for all eyeliners. However this product pleasantly surprised me-- it barely melted...

    About reviewer (17 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinCombination, Fair-Medium

    HairBlack

    EyesBrown

    4.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    JESSICA85

    16 years ago

    This is one of my favorite waterline eyeliners. I do not use this to line my lid i use MAC fluidlines for that. This has got to have the best staying power of any pencil I have used on my waterline...

    About reviewer (82 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinAcne-prone, Medium

    HairBrunette

    EyesBrown

    3.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    hell0kitty

    16 years ago

    This is a good eyeliner, but I don't think it should be so expensive ($16). However, I LOVE the fact that it's not jet black, but more of a natural black. I guess it would be considered grayish? ...

    About reviewer (47 reviews)

    AgeUnder 18

    SkinNormal, Medium, Warm

    HairBlack, Straight, Fine

    EyesBrown

    5.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    RtiQlitQT

    16 years ago

    For the most part, I agree with jojoba's extensive review (very nice, jojoba, by the way! :-) ). However, although her review describes this as having a sheen and the manufacturer descibes the...

    About reviewer (218 reviews)

    Age44-55

    SkinCombination, Other

    HairBlond

    EyesOther

    Related Searches
    MAKE UP FOR EVER / Eyeliner