Luscious Gloss Stick

Ugh, this is SO NOT worth $12. Unfortunately I'm too lazy to return it. It does have a nice sheer pigment to it (I bought it in Cayman, a true red on the browner rather than purpler side) that's...

I can't figure if I like this color or if I want to exchange it for Capri. I got Cayman because of the 2 great reviews but I don't know if it's right for me. I was expecting somthing different....

Stumbled on this at Sephora in Downtown Seattle, and loved the color of Cayman on site. It's a warm, luscious, perfect red - perfect for me because I've been looking for a punchy, almost orangey...