this is what i always wanted spice to be!
the perfect neutral liner- not orange, not brown, not purple.
i love it!
About reviewer (30 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinVery Oily
HairBrown
EyesGreen
87%
would repurchase
4.3/5
package quality
package quality
price range
description
ingredients
IngredientsHydrogenated Palm Kernel Glycerides, Hydrogenated Palm Glycerides, Hydrogenated Vegetable Oil, Talc, Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride, Japan Fruit Wax, Tocopherol, Ascorbyl Palmitate Lip pencils may contain: Iron Oxides, Titanium Dioxide, Manganese Violet, Carmine, Bismuth Oxychloride, Mica, Red 7 Lake, Red 6, Red 28 Lake, Red 21, Yellow 5 Lake, Yellow 6, Blue 1 Lake, Yellow 10 Lake, Red 30, Red 40 Lake, May Vary.
Reviews
Reviews
I bought this product after reading all the rave reviews here. Initially, I thought Whirl looked a bit too dark for me, but once I'd applied it, I was thrilled! I lined my lips, filled them...
About reviewer (174 reviews)
Age36-43
SkinDry, Tan, Not Sure
HairBlond, Other, Other
EyesBlue
Lovely, lovely neutral "my lips but better" brownish-pink really is perfect for my fair, pinkish skintone. I love the consistency and it lasts all day. I'll definitely buy this again.
About reviewer (32 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinCombination
HairBrown
EyesBlue
I am not a lip liner person but I believe it's possible for this particular lip liner to make a convert out of me. I have tried tons of lip liners over the years - many of the "your lips but...
About reviewer (821 reviews)
Age36-43
SkinDry, Fair, Warm
HairBrown, Curly, Fine
EyesBlue
I love this lip liner. It's looks awesome with Viva glam 5 lip glass. It adds a pinkier and richer color to my pigmented lips. Will be stocking up on this stuff for sure. I reccomend this color to...
About reviewer (203 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinAcne-prone, Other, Not Sure
HairOther, Other, Other
EyesOther
What colour is this? :) i still can't decide whether it's a pinky brown or a browny pink.. either way.. it has the slightest and i mean slightest touch of mauve.. And that's what makes this a great...
About reviewer (937 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinCombination, Fair, Neutral
HairBlack, Straight, Fine
EyesBrown
this is an excellent neutral pink/brown shade that goes with so many lipsticks. i've been trying to find a this exact shade for a few years and now it's here,yay, even better that it's a regular...
About reviewer (24 reviews)
Age30-35
SkinCombination
HairBlond
EyesGreen
Finally!!! This is the YLBB l/l I have been waiting for MAC to create. I could never pull off Spice because it turns orange on me. Whirl is the perfect pink-brown and looks awesome paired with VGV...
About reviewer (22 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinCombination, Tan
HairBrown
EyesBrown
Love, love, love this! Have been using for the past few months and when deciding what to do for my lips during wedding pictures, I had to go back to this color; everthing else looked too brown or...
About reviewer (399 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Warm
HairBlack, Straight, Medium
EyesBrown
This is the perfect neutral - goes great with everything - especially my Viva Glam V lipstick and lipglass. It's slightly darker than my natural lip color - which is what I was looking for!...
About reviewer (31 reviews)
Age36-43
SkinAcne-prone, Fair-Medium
HairBrown
EyesHazel
I love the quality and the color of this l/l! Nearly compatible for all lip colors/sticks/glosses. A very creamy formula. 1.45 g are a great deal (11.5 Euros is the price in Germany). I hated MAC´s...
About reviewer (3 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinOily
HairBrown
EyesBrown
I LOVE my Whirl! I don't know how I lived with using Spice as my universal color for so long - although Spice still does work for some colors - but Whirl is so close to my natural lip color and...
About reviewer (1606 reviews)
Age
SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Warm
HairBrunette, Wavy, Medium
EyesBrown
This is a fantastic nude lip liner. It looks great for light pink lipglasses like Magic Spell and Nymphette. This is a universal nude, so anything you wear over it will be slammin. Glides on...
About reviewer (46 reviews)
Age30-35
SkinCombination
HairBrunette
EyesHazel
VERY close to my natural lipcolor. Kind of a rosy, deeper nude tone. I didn't like Spice even though everyone else does because it's almost TOO nude, but I LOVE Whirl. It's very neutral and...
About reviewer (82 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinCombination, Fair-Medium
HairBrown
EyesBrown
Wonderful MLBB color for me (NW25). Great for a nude or pink lip, and I love the texture.
About reviewer (41 reviews)
Age30-35
SkinCombination
HairBrunette
EyesBrown
Spice is supposedly a universally flattering color...not! It was so orange on me and I hated it. Luckily I went back to MAC and complained and discovered Whirl. Whirl is almost the exact shade...
About reviewer (43 reviews)
Age30-35
SkinCombination
HairBrown
EyesBrown
I love this l/l. It is like what I wanted spice to be on me. Neutral color, beautiful brownish pink. I can wear w/ every l/s and l/g shade I own. The formulation of this seems creamier than the...
About reviewer (128 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinCombination
HairBrunette
EyesBrown
Perfect, perfect liner. It was described to me as spice without the orange, and that's exactly how it looks on my lips (I'm NW20). I wear it with VGV, sequin, and any neutral/nude pinkish or...
About reviewer (52 reviews)
Age
SkinOther
HairOther
EyesOther
This is my new HG liner!
<p>
It used to be Stripdown, which tended to turn a little brown on me. Spice tended to be a bit too strong, even on my pigmented lips...
<p>
Whirl is the best of all...
About reviewer (44 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinNormal
HairBlack
EyesBrown
great color, looks good with almost any lip color or alone w/gloss. needs more staying power though
About reviewer (54 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinCombination
HairBrunette
EyesGreen
