Waterproof mascara in black

re: Waterproof Volume Riche in black. I consider myself a makeup guru esp when it comes to waterproof mascara. I am a long time contact lens wearer who works long hours and was blessed w/ greasy...

Not too thrilling for me - it clumped dispite me combing my lashes after application. Didn't flake very much. Not worth the price when I can get better mascara at the drugstore.

Sigh. I don't get it with these waterproof mascaras, they STILL smudge on me no matter what. My lashes looked nice, but there was the raccoon again!

There are better waterproof masacaras that lengthen and thicken. However, I give it a four because the formula is very light (the wettest I've come across), the color is nice and glossy, and it is...