Kajal Waterline

I had high hopes of finally finding an eyeliner that would stay on my waterline, but it wears off and smudges just like every other. It is a good enough eyeliner for my top layer, but there are...

Got this in a beauty subscription (IPSY). It's okay but as most eyeliners doesn't like to stay on my eyeballs or waterline... which is interesting because the name would indicate it should stay on...