Big Look Waterproof Mascara

I got this in a subscription box but for the life of me can't remember which one. I'm always excited to get waterproof mascaras because I have very watery eyes (thanks year-round allergies) and...

I use Pur Minerals regular Big Look mascara almost daily and love it. I wanted to try this waterproof version of Big Look and it just did not work for me. I did not get the same amount of volume...