Hold The Line Waterproof Eyeliner

I received this eyeliner in the shade "Call Me" as a free gift with purchase. It's black and creamy. I didn't think I would like it because it's one of those that goes on a little smoothly. So...

I got a mini version of this in black in a set. It was so bad I tried it once and tossed it. Really dry, not creamy or smooth at all, hard to apply. It flaked a lot during application and during...

Purchased this in "Door's Unlocked", a gorgeous, blue-based, true purple. Intended to use it on my waterline, but it quite simply would not adhere to my waterline. No color transfer at all. ...