i admit i bought it for the cute packaging. overall, i think it's average but it smears too much and ends up fading.
About reviewer (12 reviews)
AgeUnder 18
SkinCombination
HairBrunette
EyesBrown
47%
would repurchase
Reviews
Reviews
BeneFit is very in tune with pop culture, but it is a far cry from being a high-quality line. This was yet another disappointment. It wasn't as dark as I thought it would be, and it smears horribly.
About reviewer (174 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinDry, Olive
HairBrunette
EyesBrown
A chubby black pencil perfect for achieving the "naughty", smoky-eyed look. I wear it out clubbing and occasionally to other evening activities. I don't think it stays better than any of the...
About reviewer (58 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinCombination
HairBrunette
EyesBrown
I personally liked this! It glides on smooth and easy and it gives you the perfect grip with the chunky pencil. Perfect for smokey eyes, it stays on longer if you layer it with eyeshadow :)
About reviewer (37 reviews)
AgeUnder 18
SkinCombination
HairBlack
EyesGreen
I admit..I bought this for the packaging. BIG MISTAKE. This is the worst eyeliner I've ever used. It smudged terribly. The price is ridiculous for such poor quality.
About reviewer (227 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinAcne-prone, Olive
HairBlack
EyesBlack
This eyeliner was a huge disappointment. The application is erratic, it's crumbly, smears easily and the staying power is nil.
About reviewer (100 reviews)
Age30-35
SkinOther
HairOther
EyesOther
It smudges, and is not easy to apply. I like more control, and prefer fine lines, so this wasn't a smart purchase for me. If you want to look like a "bad gal," with HEAVILY lined black smoky eyes,...
About reviewer (113 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinOily, Medium
HairBlack
EyesBrown
gives really good smokey eyes and lasts well and it looks very pretty!!
About reviewer (3 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinNormal
HairBlack
EyesBrown
I'm a sucker for the cute case this comes in. I actually can't bring myself to throw it out. Oh, the eyeliner is good, too! It's big, it's black, and if you use it right, it's bad (in a good way,...
About reviewer (36 reviews)
Age36-43
SkinNormal
HairBlond
EyesBrown
This is great for sexy smoky eyes! Defenitely! Goes on smooth and lasts a while! a great product
About reviewer (50 reviews)
AgeUnder 18
SkinVery Dry
HairBrown
EyesHazel
What's the big deal? After reading the catalogs you would think this was the HG of black eyeliner. It is pretty boring and a little dry IMHO. I like Smashbox's creamy eyeliner in Caviar better for...
About reviewer (33 reviews)
Age44-55
SkinNormal
HairBrown
EyesGreen
When I wanna look like a rock star I wear Bad Gal. Really smoky, really sexy eyeliner. Unfortunately, it does tend to smear so you have to constanly be fixing your eyes when using this product. ...
About reviewer (51 reviews)
Age36-43
SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Not Sure
HairBrunette, Wavy, Coarse
EyesBlue
It said it was a long lazting liner, thick dark black. They are right about the dark black. Within 1 hour of application it had smeared onto my entire eyelid, and I had shadow on. So unless you...
About reviewer (62 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinVery Dry
HairBrunette
EyesGreen
Excellent chubby black pencil...creates great sexy, smoldering eyes.
About reviewer (61 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinCombination
HairBlond
EyesGreen
I hated this product in the beginning and left it to die in my drawer, however, a month ago my Almay liquid eyeliner ran out so I had to use this as a temporary substitute. I wouldn't be buying...
About reviewer (18 reviews)
AgeUnder 18
SkinOther
HairOther
EyesOther
Benefit products are crap quality and this isn't an exception. It did go on smoothly, but it smudged and wore off within an hour and I don't have oily lids. Won't be purchasing (tried it at the...
About reviewer (67 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinOther
HairBrunette
EyesBrown
I agree with the other comments below - it is too chunky to handle, and it doesn't last on my face either. It also doesn't seem to go on very smoothly. Very disappointing.
About reviewer (19 reviews)
Age36-43
SkinOther
HairOther
EyesOther
Yes the price is a bit crazy, but I've had mine for a long time now, and I love it. Probably the only Benefit product that isn't a gimmick.
The fattness of it doesn't bother me at all, contrary I...
About reviewer (227 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinNormal, Fair, Not Sure
HairBlond, Other, Other
EyesBlue
I got this on an ebay auction for a great deal. I love it, it goes on really smooth and I dont have to PUSH onto my eyelids to make it go on! I just lightly glide it on and it gives nice defined,...
About reviewer (11 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinVery Oily
HairRed
EyesGreen
This eyeliner is amazing. A true matte black liner that goes on smooth and does not tug at the eyelid. Great for my "going out" eyes (a la Paris Hilton). Some may not like it bc it is big and...
About reviewer (20 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinOther, Other, Not Sure
HairOther, Other, Other
EyesOther
Related Searches
