Brightening Eyeliner - Noire

I think ELF is an awesome company. I bought this eyeliner simply for the pencil sharpener that came with it. I got the eyeliner + the sharpener for a $1. Are you serious??? That wasn't even a sale...

I LOVE this eyeliner. It pains to have it give it up as I am desperately trying to switch over to a healthier alternative lifestyle from my diet to my makeup so out it goes! But since I've used...