I was so excited to see that Carbon Black is now available as waterproof. However, it smudged; which to me is definitely not waterproof. Very disappointed.
About reviewer (20 reviews)
Age36-43
SkinOily, Other
HairBlond
EyesHazel
31%
would repurchase
Reviews
Reviews
This is a decent mascara at most. I wanted to get the Full Definition but they don't have it here. More volume than Maybelline One by One but that's the only good thing
*UPDATE*
it smudges...
About reviewer (381 reviews)
AgeUnder 18
SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Neutral
HairBrown, Wavy, Medium
EyesBrown
At first I was excited and had high hopes for this since it went on really black and (when wiped with a tissue) didn't clump as badly as others I've tried. But an hour later I had horrible...
About reviewer (17 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinCombination, Fair, Neutral
HairBrunette, Straight, Coarse
EyesHazel
Since I am such a fan of L'Oreal's Voluminous, I was excited to see Carbon Black. Unfortunately, it seems to be a completely different formula. It clumps, flakes, and is not even that good of a...
About reviewer (2 reviews)
Age30-35
SkinCombination, Fair
HairBrunette
EyesBrown
Hmm... this mascara is not great... but it works. I don't like it though because it doesn't curve my eyelashes at all. However, I live in a very humid tropical island, and this didn't smudge; it is...
About reviewer (39 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinAcne-prone, Fair-Medium, Not Sure
HairBrunette, Wavy, Fine
EyesBrown
Let me just say, OMGWTFBBQ, this is the absolute worse mascara I have ever tried. Within an hour I looked like I was auditioning to be a member of the band KISS. It smudged and ran under my eyes....
About reviewer (19 reviews)
Age30-35
SkinCombination, Other, Not Sure
HairBlond, Other, Other
EyesHazel
I love this mascara! I have tried MANY mascaras, from high-end to low-end brands, and I am honestly most impressed by this one. I have straight, medium length eyelashes, and I have a hard time...
About reviewer (5 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinSensitive, Fair-Medium, Warm
HairBrunette, Curly, Coarse
EyesBrown
Hm. Im surprised this has such a low rating.
Goes to show that products work differently on everyone.
I like this mascara. When I first open it up the formula looks really wet, which I dislike....
About reviewer (114 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinNormal, Fair-Medium, Warm
HairBrunette, Wavy, Coarse
EyesBrown
I thought this mascara was bad! When I put it on it totally smudged ever where and was very runny! It also clumped a lot. I Wouldn't buy it again because overall the mascara was terrible.
About reviewer (8 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinCombination, Olive, Warm
HairBrunette, Curly, Coarse
EyesBrown
Wow waste of money. Lengthens and volumizes but smudges within minutes. Thank you for making me look like a panda, L'Oreal. Will never buy again!!
About reviewer (26 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinVery Oily, Tan
HairBrown
EyesBrown
This has got to be one of the best mascara's I've ever used, I showered with it and it didn't even smudge! I love it!
About reviewer (4 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinOily, Fair
HairBrunette
EyesBlue
This was a joke! It did nothing for me. All it did was wet my lashes. And that is all......lol
About reviewer (37 reviews)
Age30-35
SkinOily, Dark, Not Sure
HairBlack, Kinky, Coarse
EyesBrown
It looked fine on, lashes looked lengthened and nice and black, but within an hour smudges galore. I used eye makeup remover, cold cream and washed my face and I still was removing the remnants the...
About reviewer (87 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinCombination, Fair, Cool
HairBrown, Wavy, Fine
EyesBrown
Smudges. Flakes. Panda eyes - need I say more?
About reviewer (128 reviews)
Age44-55
SkinCombination, Olive, Not Sure
HairBlack, Other, Other
EyesBrown
smudges & flakes everywhere. With in two hours my eyelid and underneath my eye area is covered in black. Gives ok volume but I can't deal with the flaking.
A waste of money.
About reviewer (85 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinAcne-prone, Tan, Warm
HairOther, Curly, Medium
EyesBrown
I have literaly been thru like 20 tubes of this mascara definetly my fave mascara EVER it makes my lashes look so thick,long and VOLUMINOUS.. and even better its only 5$..
About reviewer (4 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinCombination, Medium, Not Sure
HairBrown, Straight, Medium
EyesBrown
Why I did not heed the reviews is beyond me now.
I first applied, and thought WOW I love this. It looks great. Don't know what they were TALKING ABOUT. 2 hours later, it is all under my eyes. It...
About reviewer (345 reviews)
Age36-43
SkinAcne-prone, Medium, Neutral
HairOther, Wavy, Medium
EyesBlue
This is horrible. It smudges like crazy an hour after I put it on. By the end of the day it's all over my face. Absolutely NOT waterproof. I meant to buy the original Voluminous and got this...
About reviewer (4 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinCombination, Fair
HairBlond
EyesGreen
I just bought the mascara yesterday, and I'm already disappointed.
As others said, not the greatest for those who have oily eyelids. I found that after... 3 hours it smudged under my eyes, which...
About reviewer (85 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinCombination, Other, Not Sure
HairBlack, Curly, Fine
EyesOther
I have tried the non-waterproof mascara and didn't like it at all..it was too wet although this one is too is way less than the other..LOVE the volume that gives to my lashes and the thickness...
About reviewer (397 reviews)
Age30-35
SkinCombination, Tan, Neutral
HairBrown, Wavy, Coarse
EyesBrown
Related Searches
