Amazing Mascara - Waterproof

This can look very good on the shelf but it doesn' t do the job it says it does. Good price too but no. It dries out on your eyelashes and starts to fall off after half a day of wear. It irritates...

While this mascara was totally nonirritating and did not flake much, the pigment seemed to be nearly nonexistant. I got black but it did very little for my lashes.

Okay, maybe I'm weird but I like this. I have naturally dark lashes (black to be exact) and this makes my lashes look full without making them look like they'd been coated in goo. It didn't smear...

claims to lengthen and thicken, did neither! Claims to last without smudging or flaking for 16 hours, OK, try 2 hours. I got the waterproof. Had a fight with SO, I cried, it ran. All I have to say...

It was terrible; uncurled my lashes, but worst of all, smudged horribly (and it was waterproof too!)