Maximum Wear Waterproof Mascara

I am not an expert on mascaras as this is the second brand of mascara that I have tried ;however, this is very tricky to apply it always smudges on my lid and I end up having to redo my e/s. I...

This is one of the two waterproof formulas I recently bought online from Ulta.com. I don't know if mine was old, or clumpy and dry is their regular formula for this mascara. Another one for the...