Indelible Eyeliner in Penny [DISCONTINUED]

I have dark brown eyes and this is too light to be used as an eyeliner. I prefer my eyeliner to be dark. I do not regret buying it though because it makes an awesome intense eyeshadow. I only use...

Penny is just the color you'd expect -- a gorgeous shimmery copper! It's a bit lighter than I would expect for an eyeliner, so I think it looks best with lighter eyeshadow colors. It doesn't show...