Constant Color Gel Eyeliner in Indigo

UPDATE: I am seriously downgrading this product because I find that it dries up and becomes crumbly after only a couple months of use, then you have to throw it out. For a price that approaches...

I was expecting this to be a very dark, almost-black navy shade, but it's much more blue than I expected. I don't really like distinctly navy liner along my lash line. Also, Paula's gel eyeliner...