Thank you for your response! Yes, I do think it is ink.
Is it ink? Could try a spot test with a q-tip and rubbing alcohol.
Revlon Satin Ink in Eyes on You
This post is so timely - just rediscovered their Super Stay Crayon Ink in Accept a Dare in my stash!
Yep, I love the Matte Ink and Lifter Glosses. Plus their matte regular l/s are++
Tried one of the Milani Fetish Balm lipsticks - r/o
Revlon Satin Ink Eyes On You
Maybelline superstay ink crayon in treat yourself. The other ones I love are d/c’d +
Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink