update - Essie For the Twill of It and Essence Chic Reloaded are the two 'dupes' I had in my stash
Essence lash princess
Rediscovered essence #16 "Lovable" recently and now it's down to a nub. Go-to every day.
Annick Goutal Myrrh Ardente- on the box it says "A smooth and voluptuous blending of myrrh essence +