there are various types/categories of primer so here is a little list +
I had a similar situation happen several years ago...
I'm 85% sure my housekeeper stole a perfume from my house. +
MAC Vex is a whitened champagne leaning green/pink. MAC ++
Try Urban Decay Rapture (it could skew plummy or mauve depends on your coloring)++
I looked up Tease and saw that it is a cooler shade. Along the same lines I would recommend ++
so nice of you to buy your wife some new makeup :) i have a few suggestions +
Hi, for a natural look Bobbi Brown, Laura Mercier & Charlotte Tilbury are great choices++
Tarte or Urban Decay eyeshadpw palette
Maybe one of the Urban Decay Naked palettes