If the 'use by' on the packaging is 12 months & it started separating at the 11 month mark, that's++
My thoughts. You chose to spend $140 on a concealer++
I'm not understanding this. If you bought it online, where would you return it to? +
You’ve had it for a year and now you want a refund? Wow.++
Just a thought--do you put your pencils in the freezer before you sharpen? They just need to be in +
2nd both of these. The elf putty eye brightener is so quick & easy to use+