I've always thought that tightlining was to push e/s into the lashline, not into the waterline+
The PF one is a good one. At the drugstore
The big list of Cyber Monday Deals (so you can plan ahead) +++
I'm 64 and love it. Can do a good variety of looks, neutral and colorful, golden or rosy ++
FYI--the big list of Black Friday deals (sourced from Temptalia, posted here for your convenience) +
I make a DIY Fix+: I use a tiny sprayer (mostly for e/s). Boiled spring water (sterile and stays ++
Have been using Joico k-pak hydrayor intense treatment
Wet brush++
Another vote for Wet Brush (although have not tried the TT to compare)
I was sorting through some boxes and found SO much forgotten makeup including r/o