I hated Essence Lash Princess for all the reasons you listed. I'd describe my 3 HG favorites as++
It Cosmetics Superhero (NOT the wp version tho). But I HATE paying $25 for it because++
Olive is not an overtone. One's undertone is based on melanin. +
Bain De Soleil Orange Gelée Lovers Rejoice! A miracle has taken place...Rop++