Smashbox Primrose and Rimmel clear liner
The best options in gray/cool black are on Amazon+++
I will NEVER look for a cheaper dupe of a HE product. Nothing
Rimmel Stay Matte
Found one!
Rimmel Provocalips in Make Your Move
Rimmel Kate Moss 07
Rimmel exaggerate (eastend snob) and Thrive.
My only complaint with the Rimmel ones
Chanel's are ok but the gloss part is way too liquidy and I prefer the Rimmel due to the gloss .....