Check out Danessa Myricks Color Fix. She has a TON of shades on her website++
I have Wattabrat and yes it’s great BUT I’m sure there are lots of good dupes ++
Rimmel WonderCloud in Foggy Beige *HG* as a base with various shades from r/o
Rimmel Foggy Beige WonderCloud (HG) as a base with MAC Sable on the lid r/o
Rimmel East End Pink - a very light mauve-pink, no brown in it, works beautifully on pale skin.+
I have two DS faves for mauve shades (and NO HE loves btw because these are ++
Mine+
Just a rimmel liner smudged into the upper lash line
UD Space Cowboy and a smudged pencil on rop
NYX and if you have access to it, Kiko. Rimmel and Essence are pretty good too IMO