From my spreadsheet ++
A few to consider.... ++
Not straight dupes.... but Lime Crime has a sale rn, with the Venus III palette half price ++
NYX Bare With Me concealer; $TF Vervain l/s (now d/c’d of course); Beauty Pie++
The NYX liners are very similar and there are quite a few different formulas and++
There are some incredible HE ones like the Patrick Ta liners and I also LOVE the +
A few from my spreadsheet ++
I have tried EVERY brow pen in existence and the BEST imo is+
If you've got a gun to my head.... Lime Crime Venus XL 2.
Lime Crime Taupest, NYX Nude Beige lip pencils and then I mostly fill in with ++