Kosas
NYX pro fix stick is really good and I like Kosas. I am 56
Application might be key here, too+
Kosas 1.5 C
Initially the Kosas but I ended up getting the Youth to the People one.
Mostly I use Kosas Brow Pop pencil; sometimes Sephora retractable waterproof pencil, and+
Kosas Revealer Concealer