My skintone is pretty close to yours & I also have dark hair/eyes. MAC Paint Pot in Painterly works+
Kiko Milano Unforgettable waterproof mascara - I love so many DS items but this is a true holy grail
Adding Kiko Milano offering 30% off all orders $40 and up through Memorial Day. TY, Mary Ellen!
I hated Essence Lash Princess for all the reasons you listed. I'd describe my 3 HG favorites as++
If you’re looking for an affordable brand check out Moira Cosmetics (on Amazon) ++
I threw out a Kiko Milano lip pencil
Kiko Milano 3D Hydra Lipgloss - it's not sticky, stays on longer than most, reasonably priced
Kiko Milano Water Eyeshadow in Pearly Coffee or try Inglot Freedom System singles
POLL - What's on your face today? >>