Have you considered Banana Boat, Baiersdorf/Coppertone, Elta MD - those are +
MAC Sunbasque. If you need a more matte one, MAC Coppertone
I know. I saw Prism, Springshee, Coppertone. WTF?!?!?
MAC Gingerly or maybe even Coppertone look like this on me.
We are skin, hair and I too am pretty Mediterrian (very Italian). I am neutral as well, MAC nw20++
I am fair and hate bronzer too. The only one I have been able to tolerate has been NARS ++
Aveeno body wash, sometimes I use others for fun, Cerave body cream, perfume cream from fav perfume
MAC Gingerly, Sunbasque and Coppertone (nw20, deep winter).
I love Mac Burnt Pepper, Coppertone, Sunbasque++
I kind of hate bronzer and I am nw20 and agree Laguna is the "best" I have found so far. +++