I don’t know about cruelty free, but I use Eucerin Q10 for 30 years.
I find that Catrice and Essence make fab lip products, I just wish they were scent/taste-free.
I have to give a shout-out to a truly superior lip stain. I refer to +
JVN Air Dry Cream and then once hair is dry the Bread Everyday hair oil gloss ++
