Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil 931A Black

NYC New York Color

Created with Sketch.

4.0

25 reviews
68%
would repurchase
3.9/5
package quality
price range
Write Review

    Reviews

    Reviews

    3.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    lovelovelilacs

    10 years ago

    Super creamy and glides on easily but it starts to smear on my eyelids after a few hours despite being 'waterproof'. Maybe if I used primer on my eyelids beforehand it would have longer staying...

    About reviewer (24 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinOily, Medium, Warm

    HairBlack, Straight, Medium

    EyesBrown

    2.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    missbeautyqueen

    12 years ago

    Pros: - Creamy Cons: - Smudges - Not waterproof - Not good lasting power - Not good pigmentation Overall: Im not impressed with this eyeliner. For starters it says its waterproof...

    About reviewer (17 reviews)

    AgeUnder 18

    SkinCombination, Olive, Neutral

    HairBlack, Straight, Medium

    EyesBlack

    5.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    swirlygirly

    12 years ago

    This stuff is amazing! It goes on creamy, doesn't tug the skin. Easily blendable, lasts longer than any eyeliner I've ever tried and doesn't irritate my extremely sensitive eyes. I've tried...

    About reviewer (2 reviews)

    Age30-35

    SkinVery Dry, Fair-Medium, Not Sure

    HairBlack, Other, Other

    EyesHazel

    5.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    EmiriamdD

    13 years ago

    I've been using MUFE Aqua Eyes waterproof eyeliner pencil #10 in Black for a million years. Recently I was digging through my stash and found an NYC # 931A Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, also in...

    About reviewer (40 reviews)

    Age56 & Over

    SkinNormal, Fair-Medium, Neutral

    HairBlond, Curly, Medium

    EyesBlue

    3.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    Miaoudeminou

    13 years ago

    I bought this in both black & dark brown. NYC re-vamped their packaging. It looks nice,new and sleek. I don't remember trying these liners but they rock! The other day, when I had bought them, I...

    About reviewer (743 reviews)

    Age25-29

    SkinCombination, Fair, Warm

    HairBrown, Wavy, Medium

    EyesHazel

    5.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    leoisillon

    14 years ago

    I have this in Black and Dark Brown. I LOVE this eyeliner. It's amazing. It lasts and last all day long with little to no smudging or transfering. The quality of this pencil is amazing. It sharpens...

    About reviewer (222 reviews)

    Age25-29

    SkinSensitive, Olive, Neutral

    HairBlack, Wavy, Coarse

    EyesBlack

    4.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    janejp

    14 years ago

    This eyeliner stays on really well after putting it over my eyeshadow and primer. I don't have to worry about looking like a raccoon. EDIT: I lost this eyeliner and borrowed my roommates'. One...

    About reviewer (41 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinCombination, Medium

    HairBlack

    EyesBrown

    4.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    Christinaann5

    14 years ago

    I love this liner. I am always on a search 4 a pencil liner 4 my top lash line that will show up and wont rip out my lashes. So far so good with a 99cent liner. I always line my lashes aftr primer...

    About reviewer (383 reviews)

    Age25-29

    SkinNormal, Fair, Cool

    HairBlond, Straight, Coarse

    EyesBrown

    3.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    EvilyKyoko

    15 years ago

    Eh, another reject eyeliner. This stuff either flakes off or magically disappears by the end of the day. I perfer a very dark, definite, thick line, and this gave me a smudgy line. It DID go on...

    About reviewer (168 reviews)

    AgeUnder 18

    SkinDry, Medium, Warm

    HairBrown, Relaxed, Medium

    EyesBrown

    5.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    lovelyrosequitecute

    15 years ago

    overall, this is a fantastic product! the fact that it is so affordable only adds on to how great it is! usually, im not a fan of pencil eyeliners, seeing as they always transfer to my bottom...

    About reviewer (3 reviews)

    AgeUnder 18

    SkinAcne-prone, Fair-Medium, Not Sure

    HairBlack, Other, Other

    EyesBrown

    5.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    swhatever

    15 years ago

    um how do i sharpen it? sorry

    About reviewer (2 reviews)

    AgeUnder 18

    SkinAcne-prone, Fair-Medium, Not Sure

    HairBrown, Other, Medium

    EyesBrown

    2.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    channingto

    15 years ago

    Bought it for my waterline, color doesn't even transfer. Didn't like this product.

    About reviewer (261 reviews)

    AgeUnder 18

    SkinAcne-prone, Medium, Warm

    HairBlack, Other, Fine

    EyesBlack

    5.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    laurenchan88

    15 years ago

    Love! Love! Love! this eyeliner!!! it last all day long on me top and bottom (lash line and waterline) a must have for me!

    About reviewer (1 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinNormal, Olive, Not Sure

    HairBlack, Straight, Medium

    EyesBrown

    4.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    gigiberry

    16 years ago

    I have given up on finding an eye pencil that doesn't smudge on my upper lashline. On the lower lashline, this stuff seems to stay on for at least 6 hours, which is as good as it gets with my skin....

    About reviewer (101 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinSensitive, Fair, Warm

    HairBrown, Other, Other

    EyesBrown

    1.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    radiant1

    16 years ago

    Terrible smudging! I would give this a negative 5 if I could. I can't understand why anyone would like this cheap horrible pencil. It splinters, too. Dangerous to the eye. Spend a little more...

    About reviewer (52 reviews)

    Age36-43

    SkinCombination, Fair-Medium

    HairBrunette

    EyesHazel

    4.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    RtiQlitQT

    16 years ago

    This waterproof pencil liner has very rich, dark, true black color. I love the texture and application of this liner. I use this eyeliner for tightlining and it works very well, but I have yet to...

    About reviewer (218 reviews)

    Age44-55

    SkinCombination, Other

    HairBlond

    EyesOther

    4.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    courtneyjade

    16 years ago

    The very first time I used this, it was perfect, and it still is really good, but it was the best the first time for some reason. The price is dirt cheap, and I like it but I wish they could make...

    About reviewer (12 reviews)

    AgeUnder 18

    SkinAcne-prone, Fair

    HairBrunette

    EyesGreen

    5.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    nurseexec

    16 years ago

    You can't beat the price of this eyeliner. I had read reviews here, and decided to try it when the L'Oreal Le Grand Kohl I bought turned out to be smudge central. I like the color of this a...

    About reviewer (35 reviews)

    Age44-55

    SkinNormal, Fair

    HairBrunette

    EyesBrown

    3.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    vandael

    16 years ago

    Smooth and creamy, but smudges like crazy. I used to use this to line my waterline, but after a couple hours I would have raccoon eyes. Now I use it as a guideline e/l for my gel liners and to...

    About reviewer (46 reviews)

    Age19-24

    SkinCombination, Tan

    HairBlack

    EyesBrown

    4.0
    Created with Sketch.
    from
    cho_chang

    17 years ago

    this is an ok pencil, but smears too easily on me. back to revlon colorstay

    About reviewer (77 reviews)

    AgeUnder 18

    SkinAcne-prone, Fair-Medium

    HairBlack

    EyesBlack

    Related Searches
    NYC New York Color / Eyeliner