HIP High Drama Volumizing Mascara in Black-Bronze

I usually use CG Volume exact or MF's twin, but I saw this unique color and was drawn in. It's not waterproof, and I usually use waterproof formulas. So I apply my Clarin's waterproofing mascara...

This was the first time I decided to try the HIP mascara line. You can tell that L'Oreal is trying to compete with M.A.C line, but tends to fall a bit short. The shadows I have tried are pretty,...