Rouge a levres lipstick in Biscotti

This is a very beautiful sheer lipstick with an ultra-comfortable texture. The palest and my favorite of the Lise Watier Rouge Gourmand Light lipsticks. Very neutral. Very nude. Very sexy. Perfect...

Well, I bought this at SDM in Canada....aaaaand....took it back. Blech. Maybe I purchased an old tube or something, but I found it to be terrible cakey and very drab looking. And I always go for...

Very sexxxy shimmery nude that is the same idea as MAC high tea lipstick but a touch cooler. Biscotti is a shimmery cool-toned beige wiht pinky-lavender undertones. I'm a warm NC30/C3, stila 40...