Goes on easily; smudges just as easily. I have deepset hooded eyes, and this liner makes me look like a gray panda.
About reviewer (95 reviews)
Age30-35
SkinAcne-prone, Fair, Neutral
HairBrunette, Wavy, Medium
EyesHazel
59%
would repurchase
Reviews
Reviews
I love this liner! It's a charcoal grey that doesn't budge all day long. I think that it flatters my light blue green eyecolor so much. I have repurchased it a few times.
About reviewer (58 reviews)
Age30-35
SkinNormal, Medium, Warm
HairBlond, Wavy, Medium
EyesBlue
This is my favorite every day eyeliner! I know a lot of people don't care for the "gummy" consistency of the crayon liners, but I've found that, for me, it helps to keep it from smudging. This is...
About reviewer (9 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinNormal, Fair, Cool
HairBrown, Wavy, Medium
EyesBlue
I really like the charcoal liner. The pigment is just right -- you can see it and it creates definition without looking harsh on my older, fair skin. It goes on so smoothly and is easy to smudge,...
About reviewer (441 reviews)
Age44-55
SkinDry, Fair-Medium, Neutral
HairBlond, Wavy, Fine
EyesGreen
I love the colour of this liner, it's perfect for day-time wear. But, and this is a deal breaker for me, it doesn't apply smoothly. I have to go over again and again and even then it looks...
About reviewer (784 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinCombination, Fair, Not Sure
HairBrunette, Other, Other
EyesGreen
I can't speak to longevity yet, but as for color, I love it!!! It is a true charcoal shade. I have almost black hair, lashes and brows. I was using Rimmel Taupe eyeliner for a soft thickening...
About reviewer (1298 reviews)
Age36-43
SkinSensitive, Fair-Medium, Neutral
HairBrunette, Wavy, Fine
EyesBrown
Love this eyeliner pencil - nice smoky grey colour and doesn't budge all day (and I MEAN doesn't budge - even after i've washed my face twice there's usually still traces - I remove these with a...
About reviewer (37 reviews)
Age36-43
SkinCombination, Fair-Medium
HairBrunette
EyesHazel
Does not smear or fade,stays on all day long without a problem. Agree with others who complained about this eyeliner being a bit too difficult to remove,plus,wish we got a bit more product. The...
About reviewer (59 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinAcne-prone, Fair
HairBrown
EyesBlue
I was a bit disappointed in this color. Revlon Colorstay eyeliner in "Black Brown" is my staple HQ, and I was hoping that I could say the same of the Charcoal color. However, while the charcoal...
About reviewer (387 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinOily, Fair-Medium, Warm
HairBlack, Straight, Medium
EyesBlack
I used to use this all the time, until i noticed that it SMEARS terribly by a few hours. what i really like though, is that it comes on really BOLD.
About reviewer (4 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinCombination, Tan
HairBrunette
EyesBrown
Even though I don't like the packaging of this product, I'm still impressed with its lasting power. I have oily eyelids and because of that I have to be keen in choosing eyeliners. When I applied...
About reviewer (46 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinOily, Fair-Medium
HairBrown
EyesBrown
I bought this solely for my bottom waterline because my cousin swears by this eyeliner. Fail. I resembled a panda when I previewed my face on her camera. Will never buy this again. In addition,...
About reviewer (13 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Warm
HairBlack, Straight, Medium
EyesBrown
I bought this because I have blue eyes and didn't want black because it's too harsh. I tried to apply it to my waterline on the bottom and it wouldn't go on I tried the upper lash line same thing....
About reviewer (6 reviews)
AgeUnder 18
SkinCombination, Fair-Medium
HairBlond
EyesBlue
I'm on my second thingy of this eyeliner. I really like it, a lot. It goes on smooth and easy, it's in a twist-able container, and u can sharpen it with the built in sharpener to get a...
About reviewer (22 reviews)
AgeUnder 18
SkinCombination, Fair, Not Sure
HairOther, Straight, Medium
EyesHazel
I use this in black and I absolutely LOVE it! I've used MAC eyeliner and compared to this, it's way too chalky. Revlon Colorstay is by far the best eyeliner out there. Drugstore and department...
About reviewer (2 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinNormal, Fair-Medium
HairBrunette
EyesHazel
I love the navy in the colorstay but I must admit this charcoal is disappointing especially if you purchase it only to use on your waterline (which I did). It is not a strong colour for the...
About reviewer (32 reviews)
Age30-35
SkinCombination, Fair-Medium
HairBlond
EyesGreen
In the past, I have been a big fan of the colorstay automatic pencils. I stopped using them because I have found other, even softer eyeliners, but I recently rediscovered this in my stash, and I...
About reviewer (355 reviews)
Age19-24
SkinCombination, Fair-Medium, Warm
HairBrunette, Curly, Medium
EyesHazel
I have been wearing makeup for four years. I have never used up a product UNTIL this eyeliner. That's how good it is. The color is amazing! I didn't think much of it at first, but as I started...
About reviewer (66 reviews)
AgeUnder 18
SkinDry, Fair-Medium, Not Sure
HairBrunette, Straight, Fine
EyesBrown
I love this liner! I have dark brown eyes and I always wear eyeliner. My lashes are actually black, so I feel like black liner looks okay on me, but it's sometimes too harsh for every day. I try...
About reviewer (16 reviews)
Age25-29
SkinNormal, Medium
HairBrunette
EyesBrown
I got this as part of the smarteokey quad eyeshadow and mascara set. I was excited to try it on because it has this beautiful ash gray color with a hint of metallic color. But the excitement died...
About reviewer (14 reviews)
Age30-35
SkinNormal, Fair-Medium
HairBrown
EyesBrown
