Kohl Gel Eyeliner

I bought this in the blue. Really great deal on Boots online, but it did smudge... every single time. I only apply eyeliner on my upper eyelid, but within an hour, I will see traces of it on my...

The staying power on this is pretty unacceptable. It applies fine, doesn't irritate too much, but it comes off anywhere there is water, so... (I'm talking one tear even.) I know it's hard to...