Eyeliner in Black

I have 4 pencils: gold, silver and shimmery brown, rosegold. I'm not in love with colors itself the shades are tad too bright for the silver and gold, the brown bight lighter than like vs darker...

This is my favorite black pencil eyeliner ever. My HG! I even prefer it over my Urban Decay 24/7 liner. It lasts well on the waterline, is smooth and creamy, doesn't end up on my cheeks by the end...

I love this kohl pencil because it glides on so smoothly and does not pull or tug at my eye. The color is a pretty opaque black and looks great smudged. This does transfer to my top lid over...