Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner-Midnight Blue

I bought the Stile Midnight Blue Smudge Stick just a couple of days ago at Ulta and will return it. I am truly thankful for their return policy. It just doesn't perform the way I would expect an...

Not bad, my eyes always get watery so of course this is gonna smudge. but i like it for tight lining (:

still looking for an eyeliner that does NOT smudge on oily eyes. i am getting so frustrated! the only brands that are close to perfect are Chanel and Mac Powerpoints sticks. I am always trying to...