Slim Lip Pencil - 851 Black Berry

As far as I know, this is the cheapest black lip liner that works. I've heard the Nyx Retractable one has longer staying power and is smudge- and water- proof. I may try one of their lip liners...

A lot of people would classify this as a Goth pencil. It is black but if you run it next to a black pencil like Perversion you can see a slight purple tone to it. I have actually used this...