Colour Riche Smokey Eyes 934 Black Pump (quad)

I bought this hoping to use it for Halloween, but I did not. I ended up using it for daily makeup looks. Personally I really only use the lighter dark color so I can't really attest to the whole...

I'll start with the packaging. I think it's ugly, but I could live with that. The clasp on my case is really hard to open. Really hard. Either you break a nail or use a screw driver to pop it open....