Waterproof Smokey Eye Stick - Two by Four

Like many waterproof eyeliners, this product was very waxy. Consequently, application was too difficult to achieve a smoky look. Repeated passes to get a thick line just resulted in the product...

This is a terrific eyeliner for smoky eye. I have enough black liners so I got this in Two by Four, a very dark black brown (I don't understand things like pink eyeliner; what's with that?). It's...