Jillian Dempsey Professional Kohl Eye Liner-Black

I really liked this product at first, but when I needed to sharpen my pencil the kohl broke off continuously. I've wasted my money on this product.

If what you are looking for is a great black soft khol for a smokey eye look only you will love this one (then I would give it a 5 in overall rating)! The pencil doesn't tug and is very creamy....

I like this pencil because it is very soft when you put it on and is very easy to smudge HOWEVER it doesn't last very long...not sure if I will buy again. Maybe just for the smudging part.