I've used Kiehl's Creamy Avocado Eye Cream for many years & IMHO it is the best for dry undereyes. +
TO Caffeine Solution serum. For cleansing, either Neutrogena Oil Free Eye Makeup Remover ++
I used mine for Kiehl's CdC in the Anniversary sale.
Kiehl's Musk: I'm a huge musk lover, but this smells a bit fecal. Tried but too self-consc in public
TO Caffeine Solution serum is my favourite. If you like emollient formulas, Kiehl's Avocado ++
IME it starts with skin care. For concealer, I really like Mac Pro Longwear (I'm late 40s) ++
Julianne Moore & Kyra Sedgwick -- Kiehl's Musk
Yes definitely ymmv. For me, I believe it was the combo of certain ingredients plus ++
I hear you! Just look at Kiehl's. So disappointed. ++
So far just Kiehl's CdC